2020 First Round Froob Mock Draft - 6th Round

[Ash Ketchum]

Here is the list of participants:

1. Ash (Jacksonville, NYG, LAC, Arizona, Denver, Tennessee)
2. Sergeant Rubetube (Miami, Detroit)
3. Oriole81 (Las Vegas, Cleveland, New Orleans, Houston, Baltimore)
4. Beefcake (Green Bay)
5. Small Hands (Cincinnati)
6. GordonBombay (Indianapolis)
7. Sid Hartman (Washington, Seattle)
8. SKOLTROL (Kansas City, Philadelphia)
9. mglviks (TB, Jets, Atlanta)
10. bombers3shooter (Minnesota, San Francisco)
11. vikingstw (New England)

Here is the R1 Draft Order:

Round 1
1. Cincinnati (Small Hands) - QB (Alabama) Tua Tagovailoa
2. Washington (Sid Hartman) - QB (LSU) Joe Burrow
3. Detroit (Sergeant Rubetube) - Edge (Ohio State) Chase Young
4. NY Giants (Ash Ketchum) - S/LB (Clemson) Isaiah Simmons
5. Miami (Sergeant Rubetube) - OT (Iowa) Tristen Wirfs
6. LA Chargers (Ash Ketchum) - QB (Oregon) Justin Herbert
7. Carolina (Oriole81) - DT (Auburn) Derrick Brown
8. Arizona (Ash Ketchum) - OT (Georgia) Andrew Thomas
9. Jacksonville (Ash Ketchum) - OT (Alabama) Jedrick Wills
10. Cleveland (Oriole81) - CB (Ohio State) Jeffrey Okudah
11. NY Jets (mglviks) - WR (Oklahoma) CeeDee Lamb
12. Las Vegas (Oriole81) - WR (Alabama) Jerry Jeudy
13. San Fransisco f/Indy (B3S) - WR (Alabama) Henry Ruggs
14. Tampa Bay (mglviks) - DT (South Carolina) Javon Kinlaw
15. Denver (Ash Ketchum) - OT (Louisville) Mekhi Becton
16. Atlanta (mglviks) - Edge (LSU) K'Lavon Chaisson
17. Dallas (ORIOLE81) - CB (Florida) CJ Henderson
18. Miami f/PIT (Sergeant Rubetube) - QB (Utah St) Jordan Love
19. Las Vegas f/CHI (Oriole81) - Edge (Iowa) AJ Epenesa
20. Jacksonville f/LAR (Ash Ketchum) - CB (Alabama) Travon Diggs
21. Philadelphia (SKOLTROL) - WR (Clemson) Tee Higgins
22. Minnesota f/Buffalo (B3S) - OT (Houston) Josh Jones
23. New England (VikingstW) - LB (LSU) Patrick Queen
24. New Orleans (Oriole81) - WR (Colorado) Laviska Shenault
25. Minnesota (B3S) - CB (LSU) Kristian Fulton
26. Miami f/HOU (Sergeant Rubetube) - RB (Georgia) DeAndre Swift
27. Seattle (Sid Hartman) - CB (TCU) Jeff Gladney
28. Baltimore (Oriole81) - LB (Oklahoma) Kenneth Murray
29. Tennessee (Ash Ketchum) - OT (USC) Austin Jackson
30. Green Bay (Beefcake) - WR (LSU) Justin Jefferson
31. San Francisco (B3S) - S (Minnesota) Antione Winfield Jr.
32. Kansas City (SKOLTROL) - CB (Utah) Jaylon Johnson

Pick 33: Cincinnati Bengals - Edge (Penn State) Yetur Gross-Matos
Pick 34: Indianapolis Colts - OG (Fresno State) Netane Muti
Pick 35: Detroit Lions - OT (Boise State) Ezra Cleveland
Pick 36: New York Giants - WR (Baylor) Denzel Mims
Pick 37: Los Angeles Chargers - IOL (Michigan) Ceasar Ruiz
Pick 38: Carolina Panthers- CB (Virgina) Bryce Hall
Pick 39: Miami Dolphins - S (Alabama) Xavier McKinney
Pick 40: Houston Texans (via Arz) - LB (Wisconsin) Zach Baun
Pick 41: Cleveland Browns - OL (Georgia) Isaiah Wilson
Pick 42: Jacksonville Jaguars - WR (TCU) Jalean Ragor
Pick 43: Chicago Bears - S (LSU) Grant Delpit
Pick 44: Indianapolis Colts - DT (TCU) Ross Blacklock
Pick 45: Tampa Bay Buccaneers - RB (Wisconsin) Jonathan Taylor
Pick 46: Denver Broncos - CB (Mississippi State) Cam Dantzler
Pick 47: Atlanta Falcons - CB (Auburn) Noah Igbinoghene
Pick 48: New York Jets - OT (Washington) Trey Adams
Pick 49: Pittsburgh Steelers - QB (Washington) Jacob Eason
Pick 50: Chicago Bears - Edge (Boise State) Curtis Weaver
Pick 51: Dallas Cowboys - CB (Clemson) AJ Terrell
Pick 52: Los Angeles Rams - RB (Ohio State) JK Dobbins
Pick 53: Philadelphia Eagles - LB (Oregon) Troy Dye
Pick 54: Buffalo Bills - OG (Ohio State) Jonah Jackson
Pick 55: Atlanta Falcons - DT (Oklahoma) Neville Gallimore
Pick 56: Miami Dolphins - OG (Georgia) Solomon Kindley
Pick 57: Houston Texans - WR (Arizona St) Brandon Aiyuk
Pick 58: Minnesota Vikings - DL (TAMU) Justin Madubuike
Pick 59: Seattle Seahawks - IOL (LSU) Lloyd Cushenberry
Pick 60: Baltimore Ravens - RB (LSU) Clyde Edwards-Helaire
Pick 61: Tennessee Titans - WR (Penn State) KJ Hamler
Pick 62: Green Bay Packers - DT (Alabama) Raekwon Davis
Pick 63: Kansas City Chiefs - RB (FSU) Cam Akers
Pick 64: Seattle Seahawks - WR (USC) Michael Pittman Jr.

Round 3

65. Cincinnati - OG (Clemson) John Simpson
66. Washington - OT (TCU) Lucas Niang
67. Detroit - CB (Ohio State) Damon Arnette
68. NY Jets f/NYG - OLB (Alabama) Terrell Lewis
69. Carolina - TE (Notre Dame) Cole Kmet
70. Miami - Edge (Michigan) Josh Uche
71. LA Chargers - RB (Utah) Zach Moss
72. Arizona - WR (South Carolina) Bryan Edwards
73. Jacksonville - IOL (Wisconsin) Tyler Biadasz
74. Cleveland - Edge (Notre Dame) Julian Okwara
75. Indianapolis - WR (Michigan) Donovan Peoples-Jones
76. Tampa Bay - OT (UCONN) Matt Peart
77. Denver - WR (Minnesota) Tyler Johnson
78. Atlanta - OG Damian Lewis
79. NY Jets - CB (Notre Dame) Troy Pride
80. Las Vegas - QB (Oklahoma) Jalen Hurts
81. Las Vegas f/CHI - G (Oregon) Shane Lemieux
82. Dallas - OT (Auburn) Prince Tega Wanogho
83. Denver f/PIT - DL (Missouri) Jordan Elliott
84. LA Rams - LB (Texas Tech) Jordyn Brooks
85. Detroit f/PHI - WR (Notre Dame) Chase Claypool
86. Buffalo - TE (Purdue) Brycen Hopkins
87. New England - WR (Ohio State) KJ Hill
88. New Orleans - Edge (Florida) Johnathan Greenard
89. Minnesota - WR (Liberty) Antonio Gandy Golden
90. Houston - DT (Ohio State) Davon Hamilton
91. Las Vegas f/SEA via HOU - CB (Tulsa) Reggie Robinson
92. Baltimore - OT (Lousiana) Robert Hunt
93. Tennessee - CB (Iowa) Michael Ojemudia
94. Green Bay - LB (App State) Akeem Davis-Gaither
95. Denver f/SF - OL (St. John's) Ben Bartch
96. Kansas City - DT (Auburn) Marlon Davidson
97. Cleveland f/HOU* - OL (Missouri) Yasir Durant
98. New England* S (Lenoire-Rhyne) Kyle Dugger
99. NY Giants*- IOL (Kentucky) Logan Stenberg
100. New England* - DL (Baylor) James Lynch
101. Seattle* - S (So. Illinois) Jeremy Chinn
102. Pittsburgh* - WR (UCF) Gabriel Davis
103. Philadelphia- Edge (Tennessee) Darrell Taylor
104. Los Angeles Rams- LB (Ohio State) Malik Harrison
105. Minnesota- CB (Louisiana Tech) Amik Robertson
106. Baltimore- WR (Florida) Van Jefferson

ROUND 4

107. Cincinnati- LB (LSU) Jacob Philips
108. Washington - S (Cal) Ashtyn Davis
109. Detroit - G (Michigan) Ben Bredeson
110. NY Giants - C (Washington) Nick Harris
111. Houston f/MIA - OL (Kansas) Hakeem Adeniji
112. LA Chargers - ILB (Cal) Evan Weaver
113. Carolina - DT (Utah) Leki Fotu
114. Arizona - Edge (Tulsa) Trevis Gipson
115. Cleveland - WR (Texas) Devin Duvernay
116. Jacksonville - QB (Georgia) Jake Fromm
117. Tampa Bay - S (Clemson) K'Von Wallace
118. Denver - IOL (Temple) Matt Hennessey
119. Atlanta - TE (Dayton) Adam Trautman
120. NY Jets - C (Texas) Zach Shackleford
121. Las Vegas - LB (Wyoming) Logan Wilson
122. Indianapolis - LB (Alabama) Anfernee Jennings
123. Dallas - TE (FAU) Harrison Bryant
124. Pittsburgh - OG (UL-L) Kevin Dotson
125. New England f/CHI - TE (Washington) Hunter Bryant
126. LA Rams - CB (UCLA) Darnay Holmes
127. Philadelphia - OL (Oregon) Calvin Throckmorton
128. Buffalo - DL (Syracuse) Alton Robinson
129. Baltimore f/NE - Edge (Florida) Jabari Zuniga
130. New Orleans - CB (Nebraska) Lamar Jackson
131. Arizona f/HOU - OL (SDSU) Keith Ismael
Minnesota- WR (Memphis) Antonio Gibson
Seattle- WR (SMU) James Proche
Baltimore- C (Mississipi St) Darryl Williams
Pittsburg- TE (Vanderbilt) Jared Pinckney
Green Bay- CB (Georgia Southern) Kindle Vildor
137. Jacksonville f/ SF via Den- Edge (Utah) Bradlee Anae
138. Kansas City- CB (Wake Forest) Essang Bassey
139. Tampa Bay- QB (Colorado) Steven Montez
140. Jacksonville f/ Chi- S (Utah) Terrell Burgess
141. Miami- WR (Boise St) John Hightower
142. Washington- Edge (Charlotte) Alex Highsmith
143. Atl f/ Balt- DT (Ole Miss) Josiah Coatney
144. Seattle- Edge (Notre Dame) Khalid Kareem
145. Philadelphia- RB (Boston College) AJ Dillon
146. Philadelphia- WR (Kentucky) Lynn Bowden

5th round


147. Cincinnati- TE (Missouri) Albert Okwuegbunam
148. Carolina- OT (South Carolina St) Alex Taylor
149. Detroit- S (Georgia) JR Reed
150. NY Giants- DE (Auburn) Nick Coe
151. LA Chargers- CB (Florida St) Stanford Samuels
152. Carolina- OL (Auburn) Jack Driscoll
153. Miami- TE (Cincinnati) Josiah Deguara
154. Miami- CB (Auburn) Javaris Davis
155. Minnesota- OT (LSU) Saadiq Charles
156. San Francisco- CB (Pitt)- Dane Jackson
157. Jacksonville- RB (Arizona St) Eno Benjamin
158. NY Jets- WR (Wisconsin) Quintez Cephus
159. Las Vegas- S (Iowa) Geno Stone
160. Indianapolis- QB (Washington St) Anthony Gordon
161. Tampa Bay- CB (Michigan St) Josiah Scott
162. Seattle- LB (Purdue) Marcus Bailey
163. Chicago- OL (Wake Forest) Justin Herron
164. Dallas- S (Utah) Julian Blackmon
165. Jacksonville- WR (Tennessee) Jauan Jennings
166. Detroit- RB (Appalachian St) Darrynton Evans
167. Buffalo- LB (Mississippi St) Willie Gay Jr
168. Philadelphia- CB (UCF) Nevelle Clark
169. New Orleans- RB (Maryland) Javon Leake
170. Baltimore- TE (LSU) Thaddeus Moss
171. Houston- WR (Rhode Island) Isaiah Coulter
172. New England- Edge (Miami) Jonathan Garvin
173. Miami- DB (Washington) Myles Bryant
174. Tennessee- DT (Nebraska) Khalil Davis
175. Green Bay- OL (West Virgina) Colton McKivitz
176. San Francisco- OL (North Carolina) Charlie Heck
177. Kansas City- LB (Colorado) Davion Taylor
178. Denver- S (Texas) Brandon Jones
179. Dallas- LB (Wake Forest) Justin Strnad

ROUND 6

180. Cincinnati: S (Alabama) Shyheim Carter
181. Denver: WR (Oregon St) Isaiah Hodges
182. Detroit: CB (Michigan) Lavert Hill
183. NYG: CB (Temple) Harrison Hand
184. Carolina: S (West Virgina/XFL): Kenny Robinson
185. Miami: S (Clemson) Tanner Muse
186. LAC: WR (Southern Miss) Quez Watkins
187. Cleveland: LB/S (Michigan) Khaleke Hudson
188. Buffalo: RB (Vanderbilt) Ke'shawn Vaughn
189. Jacksonville: CB (Oklahoma St) AJ Green
190. Philadelphia- Edge (Michigan St) Kenny Willikes
191. NYJ: TE (Stanford) Colby Parkinson
192. Green Bay: TE (Oregon) Jacob Breeland
193. Indianapolis: CB (San Diego St) Luq Barcoo
194. Tampa Bay: OG (Michigan) Jon Runyon
195. New England: K (Georgia) Rodrigo Blankenship
196. Chicago: WR (Virginia) Joe Reed
197. Indianapolis: RB (Florida) Lamical Perine
198. Pittsburgh: DL (North Carolina) Jason Stowbridge
199. LA Rams: DL (NC State) Larell Murchison
FULL 6TH ROUND

180. Cincinnati: S (Alabama) Shyheim Carter
181. Denver: WR (Oregon St) Isaiah Hodges
182. Detroit: CB (Michigan) Lavert Hill
183. NYG: CB (Temple) Harrison Hand
184. Carolina: S (West Virgina/XFL): Kenny Robinson
185. Miami: S (Clemson) Tanner Muse
186. LAC: WR (Southern Miss) Quez Watkins
187. Cleveland: LB/S (Michigan) Khaleke Hudson
188. Buffalo: RB (Vanderbilt) Ke'shawn Vaughn
189. Jacksonville: CB (Oklahoma St) AJ Green
190. Philadelphia- Edge (Michigan St) Kenny Willikes
191. NYJ: TE (Stanford) Colby Parkinson
192. Green Bay: TE (Oregon) Jacob Breeland
193. Indianapolis: CB (San Diego St) Luq Barcoo
194. Tampa Bay: OG (Michigan) Jon Runyon
195. New England: K (Georgia) Rodrigo Blankenship
196. Chicago: WR (Virginia) Joe Reed
197. Indianapolis: RB (Florida) Lamical Perine
198. Pittsburgh: DL (North Carolina) Jason Stowbridge
199. LA Rams: DL (NC State) Larell Murchison
200. Chicago: RB (Maryland) Anthony McFarland
201. Buffalo: WR (Miami) Jeff Thomas
202. Arizona: TE (Arkansas) CJ O'Grady
203. New Orleans: WR (Vanderbilt) Kalija Lipscomb
204. New England: Edge (North Dakota St) Derrek Tuszka
205. Minnesota: QB (FIU) James Morgan
206. Jacksonville: DT (LSU) Rashard Lawrence
207. Minnesota: S (Illinois St) Luther Kirk
208. Green Bay: S (MS St) Brian Cole
209. Green Bay: QB (Michigan St) Brian Lewerke
210. San Francisco: DT (Arkansas) McTelvin Agim
211. NY Jets: LB (Miami) Shaquille Quarterman
212. New England: G/C (Ball St) Danny Pinter
213. New England: QB (Iowa) Nate Stanley
214. Seattle: Edge (Minnesota) Carter Coughlin

[RubeTube]

Wondering when we were going to do this again.

I'm in! I would like Miami if possible.

We should probably wait until after FA.

[Ash Ketchum]

Wondering when we were going to do this again.

I'm in! I would like Miami if possible.

We should probably wait until after FA.

Right, we’ll still sign up now though. I anticipate each willing participant needing to take multiple teams.

You can have Miami.

[Oriole81]

I’ll be in, and can I take Vegas?

[Beef Supreme]

I'm only in if I can be Green Bay and take Tony Mandarich again.

[Ash Ketchum]

I'm actually gonna go ahead and grab the Jags.

[mlhouse]

I'll do Cincinnati, LA Chargers, Dallas, and Minnesota.

[Ash Ketchum]

I'll do Cincinnati, LA Chargers, Dallas, and Minnesota.

Are you going to participate in the mock legitimately or are you going to be a douche like last year and refuse to acknowledge the picks made in front if you even if you disagree with them?

[RubeTube]

I would take the Lions also.

[Ash Ketchum]

I would take the Lions also.

You got it.

Come on everyone else, sign up. It's just for fun and you don't need to do a ton of research.

[Gordonbombay]

I’ll take the colts

[Ash Ketchum]

I’ll take the colts

Who the fuck are you lol?

I don’t care though, you got em.

[Sid Hartman]

Give me whoever

[mlhouse]

I'll do Cincinnati, LA Chargers, Dallas, and Minnesota.

Are you going to participate in the mock legitimately or are you going to be a douche like last year and refuse to acknowledge the picks made in front if you even if you disagree with them?

What does that even mean? THe person who is a douche is you.

[Ash Ketchum]

I'll do Cincinnati, LA Chargers, Dallas, and Minnesota.

Are you going to participate in the mock legitimately or are you going to be a douche like last year and refuse to acknowledge the picks made in front if you even if you disagree with them?

What does that even mean? THe person who is a douche is you.

Do you not remember how you behaved in last year's mock?

[SKOLTROL]

Can I take Chiefs?

[Ash Ketchum]

You guys that only have one team, feel free to take another if you'd like.

[Oriole81]

I’ll be in, and can I take Vegas?

Can I get Cle and New Orleans too?

[SKOLTROL]

I’ll take Philly if still available.

[mlhouse]

Are you going to participate in the mock legitimately or are you going to be a douche like last year and refuse to acknowledge the picks made in front if you even if you disagree with them?

What does that even mean? THe person who is a douche is you.

Do you not remember how you behaved in last year's mock?

And what did I do that was so terrible?

[Ash Ketchum]

What does that even mean? THe person who is a douche is you.

Do you not remember how you behaved in last year's mock?

And what did I do that was so terrible?

Ignore people’s picks, chastising them because “that wouldn’t happen” and then not making your picks in accordance with what had transpired before you because you didn’t agree with it.

I’m not looking to get in a pissing match with you about it, just asking you to legitimately participate for the sake of everyone else’s enjoyment.

If you don’t like someone’s pick ahead of you, you can voice it, but don’t do what you did last year. Is that fair?

Not looking for any excuse, justification or explanation. Just a simple yes or no, can you just go along with the mock so we all can just have fun with it?

[mlhouse]

Do you not remember how you behaved in last year's mock?

And what did I do that was so terrible?

Ignore people’s picks, chastising them because “that wouldn’t happen” and then not making your picks in accordance with what had transpired before you because you didn’t agree with it.

I’m not looking to get in a pissing match with you about it, just asking you to legitimately participate for the sake of everyone else’s enjoyment.

If you don’t like someone’s pick ahead of you, you can voice it, but don’t do what you did last year. Is that fair?

Not looking for any excuse, justification or explanation. Just a simple yes or no, can you just go along with the mock so we all can just have fun with it?

Not sure what picks I "ignored" but the entire point is to make a selection within our own judgement. I think the criticism was based on not picking Haskins for Cincinnati. I said he wasn't on the board and that the picks before me were unrealistic because our mock drafters ignore the quarterback value.

TO demonstrate how inane our picks were, I selected Daniel JOnes in the 3rd round for the very team everyone jumped on my ass for.

So, your view on what was "legitimate" is just your subjective view. My view was that a legitimate pick for a team was a player that would actually be availabel at the selection. That is a legitimate process wheterh you agree or not.

[RubeTube]

And what did I do that was so terrible?

Ignore people’s picks, chastising them because “that wouldn’t happen” and then not making your picks in accordance with what had transpired before you because you didn’t agree with it.

I’m not looking to get in a pissing match with you about it, just asking you to legitimately participate for the sake of everyone else’s enjoyment.

If you don’t like someone’s pick ahead of you, you can voice it, but don’t do what you did last year. Is that fair?

Not looking for any excuse, justification or explanation. Just a simple yes or no, can you just go along with the mock so we all can just have fun with it?

Not sure what picks I "ignored" but the entire point is to make a selection within our own judgement. I think the criticism was based on not picking Haskins for Cincinnati. I said he wasn't on the board and that the picks before me were unrealistic because our mock drafters ignore the quarterback value.

TO demonstrate how inane our picks were, I selected Daniel JOnes in the 3rd round for the very team everyone jumped on my ass for.

So, your view on what was "legitimate" is just your subjective view. My view was that a legitimate pick for a team was a player that would actually be availabel at the selection. That is a legitimate process wheterh you agree or not.

One was me when I passed on a QB with the Giants right away.

You then proceeded to complain and then drafted two guys in the top 11 that were not even drafted in the 1st rd.

Can't make it up.

[Simpson Get Lifted]

And what did I do that was so terrible?

Ignore people’s picks, chastising them because “that wouldn’t happen” and then not making your picks in accordance with what had transpired before you because you didn’t agree with it.

I’m not looking to get in a pissing match with you about it, just asking you to legitimately participate for the sake of everyone else’s enjoyment.

If you don’t like someone’s pick ahead of you, you can voice it, but don’t do what you did last year. Is that fair?

Not looking for any excuse, justification or explanation. Just a simple yes or no, can you just go along with the mock so we all can just have fun with it?

Not sure what picks I "ignored" but the entire point is to make a selection within our own judgement. I think the criticism was based on not picking Haskins for Cincinnati. I said he wasn't on the board and that the picks before me were unrealistic because our mock drafters ignore the quarterback value.

TO demonstrate how inane our picks were, I selected Daniel JOnes in the 3rd round for the very team everyone jumped on my ass for.

So, your view on what was "legitimate" is just your subjective view. My view was that a legitimate pick for a team was a player that would actually be availabel at the selection. That is a legitimate process wheterh you agree or not.

Oh I see what the problem is. You should just conduct your own mock draft and GM every team.

[mlhouse]

Ignore people’s picks, chastising them because “that wouldn’t happen” and then not making your picks in accordance with what had transpired before you because you didn’t agree with it.

I’m not looking to get in a pissing match with you about it, just asking you to legitimately participate for the sake of everyone else’s enjoyment.

If you don’t like someone’s pick ahead of you, you can voice it, but don’t do what you did last year. Is that fair?

Not looking for any excuse, justification or explanation. Just a simple yes or no, can you just go along with the mock so we all can just have fun with it?

Not sure what picks I "ignored" but the entire point is to make a selection within our own judgement. I think the criticism was based on not picking Haskins for Cincinnati. I said he wasn't on the board and that the picks before me were unrealistic because our mock drafters ignore the quarterback value.

TO demonstrate how inane our picks were, I selected Daniel JOnes in the 3rd round for the very team everyone jumped on my ass for.

So, your view on what was "legitimate" is just your subjective view. My view was that a legitimate pick for a team was a player that would actually be availabel at the selection. That is a legitimate process wheterh you agree or not.

One was me when I passed on a QB with the Giants right away.

You then proceeded to complain and then drafted two guys in the top 11 that were not even drafted in the 1st rd.

Can't make it up.

Yeah. The QB that I drafted in the 3rd round in the mock was the QB the Giants actually took with the 6th overall pick. And the team that I took an offensive tackle with just took a different offensive tackle in teh draft.

YOu can't make it up, can you?

I get that the point of a Rube mock draft is to make the selections that you think the team you are being the GM would do. That is great. But I also think that this creates an unrealistic environment were the player who was the 6th overall pick went in the mid-3rd in our draft and that the more objective way of making the best pick for the Bengals, or whatever team making the pick, is to look at only the set of players that they would realistically select.

And, I still think that Ford and Taylor were the best offensive tackles in the draft last season and that some of their slip was injury and other factor related.

[hategreenticemase]

Not sure what picks I "ignored" but the entire point is to make a selection within our own judgement. I think the criticism was based on not picking Haskins for Cincinnati. I said he wasn't on the board and that the picks before me were unrealistic because our mock drafters ignore the quarterback value.

TO demonstrate how inane our picks were, I selected Daniel JOnes in the 3rd round for the very team everyone jumped on my ass for.

So, your view on what was "legitimate" is just your subjective view. My view was that a legitimate pick for a team was a player that would actually be availabel at the selection. That is a legitimate process wheterh you agree or not.

One was me when I passed on a QB with the Giants right away.

You then proceeded to complain and then drafted two guys in the top 11 that were not even drafted in the 1st rd.

Can't make it up.

Yeah. The QB that I drafted in the 3rd round in the mock was the QB the Giants actually took with the 6th overall pick. And the team that I took an offensive tackle with just took a different offensive tackle in teh draft.

YOu can't make it up, can you?

I get that the point of a Rube mock draft is to make the selections that you think the team you are being the GM would do. That is great. But I also think that this creates an unrealistic environment were the player who was the 6th overall pick went in the mid-3rd in our draft and that the more objective way of making the best pick for the Bengals, or whatever team making the pick, is to look at only the set of players that they would realistically select.

And, I still think that Ford and Taylor were the best offensive tackles in the draft last season and that some of their slip was injury and other factor related.

It's a sad day when I have to take the side of the VI and say he is probably right and you were the jackass in the situation. For God sakes, can you let the kids know the last day you had any sort of significant fun? I'm gonna guess March 25, 1989.

Ash is trying to put a fun, fuck around draft deal where, you know, it's just a casual every dumbass pretend they are gm for a day deal, and you have to explain in great detail why you being a prick the last time wasnt really being a prick and how stupid it was that rubes messing around was.

Hint, the way to answer his question was - "no, won't be a problem". Good God.

[hategreenticemase]

Btw Ash, I'd jump in but hectic as shit has been I never know my schedule so I wouldnt want to hold you up.

[mlhouse]

One was me when I passed on a QB with the Giants right away.

You then proceeded to complain and then drafted two guys in the top 11 that were not even drafted in the 1st rd.

Can't make it up.

Yeah. The QB that I drafted in the 3rd round in the mock was the QB the Giants actually took with the 6th overall pick. And the team that I took an offensive tackle with just took a different offensive tackle in teh draft.

YOu can't make it up, can you?

I get that the point of a Rube mock draft is to make the selections that you think the team you are being the GM would do. That is great. But I also think that this creates an unrealistic environment were the player who was the 6th overall pick went in the mid-3rd in our draft and that the more objective way of making the best pick for the Bengals, or whatever team making the pick, is to look at only the set of players that they would realistically select.

And, I still think that Ford and Taylor were the best offensive tackles in the draft last season and that some of their slip was injury and other factor related.

It's a sad day when I have to take the side of the VI and say he is probably right and you were the jackass in the situation. For God sakes, can you let the kids know the last day you had any sort of significant fun? I'm gonna guess March 25, 1989.

Ash is trying to put a fun, fuck around draft deal where, you know, it's just a casual every dumbass pretend they are gm for a day deal, and you have to explain in great detail why you being a prick the last time wasnt really being a prick and how stupid it was that rubes messing around was.

Hint, the way to answer his question was - "no, won't be a problem". Good God.

IT isn't being a "prick" at all. They selected the way THEY wanted to make their selection and I selected the way I wanted to make the selection. I did nto want to select a quarterback for the Cincinnati pick because I did not see them selecting a quarterback no matter WHO was available in the Rube Mock Draft. So, who really was being a douche? Certainly wasn't me. I was making the subjective pick of my team I was the GM for. Those pricks were criticizing it for stupid reasons. So, lets make that clear.

[Ash Ketchum]

It’s fine.

I was just looking for mlhouse to simply say he’d play nice, instead, predictably we got a novel about why his way was the right way and the rest of us who were just trying to have a good time were wrong.

We’ll just exclude him. No big deal.

mlhouse’s teams are open.

[Ash Ketchum]

We can do multiple rounds too if people are wanting to.