T_J wrote: ↑Wed Oct 17, 2018 1:24 pm
mlhouse wrote: ↑Wed Oct 17, 2018 12:13 pm
Of course, that is balanced by the fact that McHale after 2004 couldn't make a good move to save his soul. In my opinion,
McHale brilliantly ran this team for 8 years. If he would have retired after the 03-04 season people in the NBA would have considered him one of the best NBA GMs ever. Who could have predicted he would make such bad decisions after?
This is a preposterous statement. The Joe Smith fiasco tainted anything Mchale ever did which was BEFORE the Cassell/Sprewell all in year.
McFail was a failure big time before and after the one great season in 30 years. He wasted a top 15 all time talent for over a decade aside from one year.
You gotta be kidding me.
Sorry, but you are the one making a preposterous statement, although a lot of the Rubes here will agree with you.
First, when McHale took over the team in 1995 from Jack McCloskey this was a franchise that was going absolutely and positively no where. Over the course of its history the team had won 22, 29, 15, 19, 20, and 21 games, 126 - 366 record. Turning that into a playoff team in less than 2 years was an amazing turnaround that McHale deserves enormous credit for. While most of you think that it was no big deal, drafting a high school player like Garnett with the 5th overall pick was an incredible risk and then being able to make the deal for Stephon Marbury the next season built a foundation that could have been a very competitive team.
Second, when Stephon Marbury went off the reservation, McHale did a great job of trading out of it and then when Terrell Brandon career was ended by a knee injury McHale not only maintained the team in the playoffs, it got better. In fact, two years after Brandon's career was effectively over, Brandon was traded in a 4 team trade that brought Sprewell to the Wolves.
Third, and this I have gone over and over again, the Joe Smith trade was not the "debacle" that people like you make it out to be. Sure, I agree that losing assets is a bad thing, but you seem to be of an age where your experience with teh Wolves draft position is at the top of the draft. Instead, the team lost what would have been the 25th overall pick in 2001, the 26th in 2002, we drafted Ndubi Ebi 26th on 2003, and the the 29th overall pick in 2004. Big fucking deal.
The Timberwolves were a top level team of that era and very late first round draft picks that were due guaranteed contracts meant very little to the viability of the team. In fact, because they did not have to guarantee a contract to a first round pick, it gave them added roster flexibility. In the offseason before the 2001-02 season, without a first round pick, they added Gary Trent AND JOE SMITH as a free agents. The next season they signed Troy Hudson as a free agent.
In the offseason of the 2003-04 season they added through trades Sam Cassell and Latrell Sprewell, and also added Trenton Hassell, Mark Madsen and Fred Hoiberg as free agents. This was the greatest season in the history of the franchise with 58 wins and advancement to the Western Conference championship, and despite not having first round picks, THREE OF THE STARTING PLAYERS FROM THAT TEAM WERE ADDED IN THE OFFSEASON. Of the 6 players that played in at least 70 games that season, Garnett, Cassell, Sprewell, Hassell, Hoiberg, and Madsen, FIVE OF THEM WERE ADDED THE PREVIOUS OFFSEASON.
Sorry, but the claim that prior to the 2003-04 season McHale wasn't a great success story as a GM is complete and utter bullshit, and claiming that the Joe Smith "fiasco" had any real impact on the team is even more bullshit.